Ordering a custom cake for the first time can feel like a big step. It doesn’t need to be. Here is exactly how it works when you order from me, so you know what to expect at every stage.

Step 1: Reach out early

For a wedding cake, please contact me 2 to 3 months before your date. For birthdays, baby showers and parties, 2 to 3 weeks ahead is ideal. Popular weekends fill first. If your date is sooner, ask anyway. I accept last-minute requests whenever my calendar allows.

Step 2: Send me the details

You can fill out the order form, call or text me, or send an email. The more you share, the better I can plan. These are the things I always need:

  • Your date and whether you’d like pickup or delivery.
  • Your guest count, so I can size the cake. My serving size guide can help.
  • Your occasion and theme, plus your colors.
  • Inspiration photos. Cakes you love, your invitation, decorations or anything that captures the feeling you want.
  • Any dietary needs. Every cake I make is egg-free. If you also need dairy-free or have an allergy to mention, tell me up front.

Step 3: We talk it through and I send your quote

Together we go over flavors, fillings, frosting, size and style. Then I send you a personal quote. Because every cake is designed from scratch, the price depends on the size, the number of tiers and the design details, so there is no one-size price list.

Step 4: Your deposit reserves the date

Once you’re happy with the plan, your deposit reserves your date on my calendar. From there, I sketch, bake and decorate your cake by hand, fresh for your celebration.

Step 5: Pickup or delivery

You can pick up your cake from my studio in New Berlin, or delivery can be arranged. Delivery options for your date and location are confirmed in your quote. Before you head home, read my tips on transporting and storing your cake.

Not sure what flavor to choose?

Start with my favorite flavor pairings, or browse the full menu before we talk.

Quick answers

How far ahead should I order a custom cake?

For wedding cakes, reach out 2 to 3 months ahead. For birthdays, showers and parties, 2 to 3 weeks is ideal. Last-minute requests are accepted when the calendar allows.

What information do I need to order a custom cake?

Your date, guest count, occasion and theme, colors, inspiration photos, any dietary needs, and whether you want pickup or delivery.

How much does a custom cake cost?

Every cake is designed from scratch, so the price depends on the size, number of tiers and design details. You receive a personal quote after a consultation.

Do you deliver custom cakes?

Cakes can be picked up from the New Berlin studio, or delivery can be arranged. Delivery options are confirmed in your quote.