One of the first choices in designing a cake is buttercream or fondant. There’s no wrong answer. They simply do different jobs, and many cakes use both.

What is buttercream?

Buttercream is a soft, creamy frosting spread and smoothed over the cake. It can be finished smooth and clean, textured, or piped into rosettes, ruffles and flowers. On my menu you can choose Buttercream, Butter Whipped or Cream Cheese frosting, and all of them are egg-free.

What is fondant?

Fondant is a smooth sugar paste rolled out into a thin sheet. It can cover a whole cake for a flawless, porcelain-like finish, or be shaped into figures, bows, lettering and other decorations.

How they compare

ButtercreamFondant
LookSoft, creamy, textured or pipedVery smooth, crisp edges, bold colors
TextureCreamy and lightSmooth and a little chewy
Best forFlorals, rosettes, drips, rustic and elegant finishesSculpted cakes, character figures, sharp patterns, quilting
Warm weatherSofter, so keep it coolHolds its shape well, but still keep it out of the sun

When I suggest buttercream

If you love a soft, romantic look, buttercream is beautiful. Rosette dress cakes, piped flowers, ruffles and drip cakes are all buttercream designs. It’s also a favorite for guests who want lots of creamy frosting in every bite.

When fondant makes sense

Fondant shines when a design needs structure or sharp detail: a sculpted truck or spellbook, a draped princess gown, quilted tiers or a figure on top. These are the designs where a smooth, firm surface makes the details possible.

The best of both

Many of my cakes are covered in buttercream with handmade fondant decorations on top, like figures, bows, lettering or toppers. You get the taste of buttercream with the detail of fondant. Browse my portfolio to see both styles, and bring your favorites to our consultation.

Quick answers

What is the difference between buttercream and fondant?

Buttercream is a soft, creamy frosting that can be smoothed, textured or piped. Fondant is a smooth sugar paste rolled into sheets to cover a cake or shaped into decorations.

Which is better for a sculpted or character cake?

Fondant, because its smooth, firm surface holds shapes, figures and sharp details.

Can a cake have both buttercream and fondant?

Yes. Many custom cakes are frosted in buttercream and decorated with handmade fondant figures, bows, lettering or toppers.

Are the frostings egg-free?

Yes. Buttercream, Butter Whipped and Cream Cheese frostings at Cakes by Ripal are all egg-free.